Fullmetal Alchemist: a Review

Written by on December 11th, 2010

Whether you are new to anime, or you are a seasoned veteran but have never seen the series; I highly recommend the show Fullmetal Alchemist to anyone who wants an amazing anime to either start, or add to your list of favorites. This series has an outstanding plot that has landed it in countless ‘top 10 anime series of all time’ lists. The character development is so thorough; you may actually find yourself upset if something were to happen to one of them. With a total of 51 episodes, a concluding movie, and my favorite award winning voice actor Vic Mignogna, this series is my personal all-time favorite, and I hope it will be yours too.

The series starts off with a little character introduction, naturally, of the protagonists: Edward and Alphonse Elric; two brothers whom you shortly learn have nothing but each other.

It all begins when the pair of young brothers, eager to commence a complex experiment involving a large circle with specific, detailed markings within it. The older brother, Ed, activates the circle with his younger brother, Al, and narrates while you watch them seemingly pleased, so far. Ed begins to describe the experiment as Alchemy, a “science of understanding the structure of matter, breaking it down, then reconstructing it as something else… to obtain, something of equal value must be lost” as it is the “law of equivalent exchange”. Immediately following the explanation of this law, the cheery mood completely changes.

The once positive Ed instantly shows terror on his face as his ‘perfect’ experiment is about to become the most traumatizing moment of his life. After a brief cut-away to a dark, stormy night sky, you return to the room with Ed, now severely wounded and alone. You see Al’s clothes through the mist. He calls out to his brother, to no avail. And just when things seem to have taken a turn for the worse, there is a sign of hope, as Ed looks upon his ‘creation’ potentially pleased. But within the circle is a grotesque silhouette of a demonic looking creature, clearly, not the results the boys were looking for. You are quickly led to believe that the two have dabbled with a very dangerous art.

Though the introduction to the series is very dark and gory, the show itself is rather comedic a lot of the time. I think it has a perfect balance of seriousness, action, comedy, and gore, which makes it simply amazing. The plot truly begins on episode three, where Ed and Al are young; it shows their background and the show continues from there with a jump of a couple of years to when they are teens. The first two episodes take place in a desert where the teenage brothers are on official military duty. These episodes throw you right into the action and world they live in, which, as far as technology goes, is around the early 1900’s, but with the mysterious science of Alchemy. In fact, the theme of Alchemy references an actual science practiced hundreds of years ago; but obviously, it was unsuccessful for us…

Anyway, if you do watch anime and you have not seen this show, shame on you! And as a side note, there is actually a spinoff series called Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood.

This series isn’t a sequel, or a side story, but an entirely new storyline. All of the classic characters are there, with the introduction of some new ones. If anything, Brotherhood may actually be better than its predecessor, in my own opinion. Currently, there are only 26 episodes dubbed in English, however, all 64 episodes are completed in Japanese with English subtitles, if you don’t mind the voices. In the English dub, many of the original voice actors have returned, thank god.

You don’t necessarily need to watch the original series before checking this one out, as the stories aren’t dependent on each other; but I do recommend watching them in order. That being said, I really hope you enjoy this outstanding anime as much as I do!

  • Hadam10Rose

    brotherhood was and still remains to be the biggest peace of bull I have ever seen. (A Chibi moment every 10-15 seconds) The story was on speed, and (Spoiler) with its happy happy disney ending made me laugh at thinking I ever liked that story.

    The original anime on the other hand, was the only anime I could stand to watch. And that says a lot, the 2005 Fullmetal Alchemist got a anime-hater to watch and like there story, while brotherhood was just more of the same old anime bull.

    • AEckoOfDeath

      Brotherhood is the completed manga story line (the actual story line) well the “first” took the uncompleted manga which was wildly popular and add a lot of filler and gave it’s own vision of the story, so this made brotherhood rushed. So each have their own story and both are great in their own way.

      • Hadam10Rose

        what made brotherhood ‘rushed’ is the fact that they Cut whole story arcs out, and added other, and changed more (The First Episode Completely , Father Carmelo Hulking Out, and the Entire Greed Story Arc ‘in the manga Ed was not even in town when Al was taken ‘To get his State Liston Renewed and Teacher came in to save Al, Lost to Greed and then Ed went in, almost won, but the furher showed up. In Brotherhood Ed was in town, went to Fight Greed first and Teacher came in to save the day, but furhur showed up’ I could go on about the differences between the two ‘Manga and Brotherhood’ but I don’t want to start a fight.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_LCSDLGUZVR2CSAOH5K2D2GLJUM =]

      I wouldn’t say there was a chibi moment every 15 seconds that is clearly exaggerating it. Brotherhood actually has a morale to life while the first season doesnt really leave the viewer with something to leave with. Just because it ends on a happy note doesnt mean that the season is ruined, their were still alot of deaths in the series overall.

      • Hadam10Rose

        yes, all the bad guys and some minor characters.

      • Hadam10Rose

        Time them.

    • Rudedogmc3

      i’ll admit, FMA is a great series, and i love it since i grew up watching it. but brotherhood is much more epic in everyway, and the characters are just better in general, especially edward, considering the fact that you could actually see him growing up throughout the series.

      • Hadam10Rose

        Edward didn’t grow in the original, because (as in the manga and brotherhood) all his extra energy went to Al’s body at/in the gate. Well in the original anime they were never close enough to Al’s body. In brotherhood and the manga, once Ed saw Al’s body Al began to help feed his own body. (That is why Al could clap and use Alchemy instead of needing a circle.

    • Varunsmathur

      Dude brotherhood was made when the FMA manga was completed. Unlike its predecessor it sticks completely to the manga. So basically what u are saying is that the manga (which led to the anime in the first place) is bull. That makes no sense man

      • Hadam10Rose

        Before you anime lovers get all in an up roar do yourselves a favor go back and read the Greed story arc (First Greed not Lin (Ling if you read the boot leg version online or are a none English reading country’s) and you’ll see right off the bat that your precious brotherhood is not a exact moving replica of the manga. Hell read chapter 2 and see how Father Carmelo does NOT hulk out, the way he does in brotherhood. Once you read the manga over again and then watch brotherhood, you will see that story arcs are cut out or changed or pop up out of nowhere (aka Episode 1 of brotherhood). Furthermore the chibi scenes that where funny in the manga barely appear or not at all, and in brotherhood ones that never happen in the manga appear in brotherhood.
        And yes brotherhood and the manga are a happy happy ending, everyone gets what they want and that is why I don’t like brotherhood of the manga. (I used to Love the manga, but the ending changed my mind)

    • Bassmonkey

      Brotherhood was more like the original story. Moreover, what’s wrong with chibi? It’s called comic releif.
      The story of the first anime made me laugh. It was tight and well knited together in the manga, then the anime changed ti all and things don’t go so well. I watched the anime first, but after watching Brotherhood i knew it was really a load of bull. They even jumbled characters around in some cases, placing **spoiler** Bradley as Pride instead of Selim, and Izumi’s child instead of Bradley. If there’s one thing i can’t stand, it’s changing characters around. In the first anime, they severely screwed up the concept of homunculi as well.
      However, Brotherhood laves a few bits out, so for the best version of the story i recommend the Manga.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_LCSDLGUZVR2CSAOH5K2D2GLJUM =]

    The reviewer should at least know that the Brotherhood series follows the manga. Its not really a spin off series.

    • Hadam10Rose

      Well it is more closer to the manga, but not and exact following

  • Nlinn

    fullmetal alchemist brotherhood is actually more of a reboot of the series than a spin-off, where it follows the manga exactly to a tee. the first series branched off and changed the story halfway through to its own storyline.

    • Hadam10Rose

      Not really to a ‘tee’ as you say. It cut many of the good Chibi moments and add bad one. And change some aspects of the story (Like Father Carmelo Hulking Out and the Entire 1st Episode, also the entire Greed story arc is cut down)

  • Pingback: Steampunk 101 | Lytherus

  • Fwacha!Dragonrider180

    does anyone know a good site to find viewable episodes (free and not ill eagle)?

    • Hadam10Rose

      In the USA Youtube for Japanese episodes for brotherhood) with English subs. And English Dubbed for the Origanil Fullmetal Alchemist anime, also on youtube

      • Fwacha!Dragonrider180

        Thanks! But I tried that, I couldn’t view or find all the episodes…. I appreciate the help! I’ll just have to rent it on itunes…..

    • anime freak

      anime freak is a great website for checking out anime and manga. It’s updated every day and has almost everything you could want to watch!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Hadam10Rose

    Also in brotherhood, if you never read the manga. Yoki joins Scar (This was not mentioned in the series) because he try to turn him in to the military with the help of these biker looking guys and when Scar kills the guys, he spare Yoki’s life and Yoki goes on his journey with Scar. More stories are cut, so if you want the “Real” Fullmetal Alchemist Story, do not watch brotherhood, read the manga.

    • Fwacha!Dragonrider180

      Always the case with TV.

  • Pingback: Anime Recommendations 1 | Lytherus

  • abe

    FMA (2003) diverts from the original manga story because the manga could not keep up at the time.
    FMA brotherhood (2009) follows the manga and isn’t a spin-off.

    However there are some who will fight me to say the 2003 version is the only good one. Both are great although i’d recommend you watch the brotherhood version first then watch the 2003 version.

  • http://twitter.com/darkwarthog Erica Wilkinson

    READ THE MANGA! It’s so much better than the anime!! :D

    • Bryce Hilton

      The manga is pretty good but I hope you still like the anime too. Everybody seems to hate it for some reason :(

  • shardaeiris

    Ha, wow, I never thought I’d see the day that Fullmetal Alchemist was famous in the western world so much I’d stumble a review on it…thinking about it, I was only twelve when I first watched this, but till today its still my favourite story (anime, books whatever).

    Haven’t watched brotherhood or finished the manga completely, but from the sounds of it, its just the Manga’s plot, not an entirely new storyline? But yes, FMA definitely gives other authors/artists a run for their money :D
    Sadly though, now I have to leave the FMA fandom cause ending spoilers is cropping up everywhere.

    • http://www.twitter.com/mikemacauley Mike Macauley

      I’ve been watching Brotherhood (slowly) after watching the original FMA series twice. I’m only about 12 episodes into Brotherhood but so far it has followed the original anime series fairly closely (I haven’t read the manga) but I’ve been told to expect deviations in the end of the show. I guess we’ll see how that goes.

    • http://www.twitter.com/mikemacauley Mike Macauley

      I’ve been watching Brotherhood (slowly) after watching the original FMA series twice. I’m only about 12 episodes into Brotherhood but so far it has followed the original anime series fairly closely (I haven’t read the manga) but I’ve been told to expect deviations in the end of the show. I guess we’ll see how that goes.

  • foohey

    Fullmetal is great!! Though FMA brotherhood is better in my opinion.
    You can also read the manga too.

  • Bbh2186

    the manga was much better than the TV show

  • bob

    pretty sure brotherhood is closer to the original manga… as the first fma anime was “too fast” for the manga, and so they made stuff up

  • Hakumei1993

    The manga and Brotherhood are near identical.

  • BWD

    Oh God, the Original one is so much better than Brotherhood. I really have a very strong dislike of Brotherhood, I found it rather shallow. The first one is just so full of emotion and I found myself crying at times, screaming and begging for everything to be ok. 

    Vic and Aaron do amazing jobs as their roles of Ed and Al respectively.

    Brotherhood was flat, shallow and awful, from the storyline to the art and animation. I recommend the 2003 one. This was my second anime to watch and I have not regretted it. Brotherhood was a slap in the face for us 2003 fans, it laughed at us and turned our beloved series into a steaming pile of dung.

    ‘Nough said. If you don’t like it, I don’t care, this is my opinion.

    Long live 2003!!!

    2003 Homunculi = <3333333333333333 (Wrath!)